The Bear Season 3 Confirms Claire’s Biggest Criticism Is Intentional With 1 Line From Carmy (2025)

Summary

  • Claire's tranquility in The Bear has been intentionally written to contrast with other characters, and it's not due to underdevelopment.
  • Claire's reduced presence in The Bear season 3 highlighted her importance in maintaining balance among chaotic personalities.
  • Claire's character, described as "Peace" by Carmy, plays a crucial role in bringing a unique element to The Bear's storyline.

The Bear season 3 includes a line from Carmen "Carmy" Berzatto that acknowledges the audience's view of Claire Dunlap is more accurate than they realize, if not a little misunderstood. Molly Gordon's character has been criticized by portions of The Bear's fan base for a very specific reason, but Carmy's appraisal of her perfectly explains why Claire conducts herself the way she does. While she may have been used sparingly in The Bear season 3's cast, it's still clear to see that Gordon's character has a very specific role in the show.

With The Bear season 4 confirmed and on the way, the show is very unlikely to address the issues some fans have with Claire's character. While her personality may be at odds with other figures within the world of the show, Carmy's description of her in The Bear season 3 perfectly justifies why his love interest sticks out among the other big personalities. While the future of Carmy's relationship with Claire may be uncertain, the future will likely keep her unchanged as the story progresses in the next run of episodes.

Related

The Bear: All 28 Episodes, Ranked From Worst To Best

The Bear has earned the title of one of television's most poignant and innovative drama series in just 3 seasons. Here are all 28 episodes, ranked.

1

Claire Isn't As Flawed As The Bear's Other Characters (& 1 Season 3 Line Confirms Why)

Molly Gordon's character stands out for being more self-assured

Carmy artfully describes Claire as "Peace" in The Bear season 3. In a whirlwind world of high standards and stressful scenarios, Carmy often finds himself in the chaotic throes of restaurant service and all related circumstances. Not only that, but Jeremy Allen White's character is endlessly processing the family trauma which has been referenced and directly shown throughout The Bear's run. From Carmy's perspective, Claire is the living antithesis of his lifestyle, despite having a medical career that's even more high-stakes than his own. In fact, she is essentially flawless when held up against any other character in The Bear.

Claire has very few scenes where Carmy isn't also there in some respect, so it highlights the fact that the audience is only really being shown an idealized version of her.

Claire has very few scenes where Carmy isn't also there in some respect, so it highlights the fact that the audience is only really being shown an idealized version of her - when she's at her best. However, it's also clear that Claire has far less emotional baggage than the rest of the show's characters, and she conducts herself in a much less intense way and with none of the aggression displayed by her friends and associates.

Carmy Calling Claire "Peace" Proves She's Intentionally Written The Way She Is

Claire isn't the underdeveloped character some fans perceive her to be

Without Carmy's apt description of Claire being "Peace," it can seem like Claire is simply an underdeveloped character when compared to the others. She's never flying off the handle or engaging in bitter feuds over petty subjects, which can arguably make her stand out for all the wrong reasons. However, it's not that the writers have simply not worked on Claire's character less than the others, it's that she's supposed to be as level-headed and self-assured as she is. It may seem jarring in a world of hotheads, but that's kind of the point.

If The Bear's writers had made Claire more similar to the other characters in the show, she wouldn't have offered anything new to the story.

If The Bear's writers had made Claire more similar to the other characters in the show, she wouldn't have offered anything new to the story. By having her demeanor stand out as being calm and straightforward, it pulls the focus to Claire and makes everything happening around her seem even more dramatic, or sometimes even more trivial. Carmy's appraisal of Claire as a peaceful character is essentially the writers telling the viewers that they're aware Claire is a uniquely tranquil figure and that it's a conscious decision to make her that way rather than being the result of a lazy oversight.

The Bear Season 3 Made Claire Easier To Appreciate

Claire's reduced presence in season 3 highlights her importance to the show's formula

The Bear Season 3 Confirms Claire’s Biggest Criticism Is Intentional With 1 Line From Carmy (3)

Claire was one of the biggest introductions to The Bear's season 2 cast, but her role was incredibly muted by comparison when it came to her The Bear season 3 episodes. The beginning of her courtship with Carmy showed a noted change in his character, as he became less intense - although also less focused ahead of the new restaurant's launch. Having Claire act the way she does around so many chaotic individuals also brought focus to the most bizarre facets of how they all conducted themselves. With her appearing so sporadically throughout The Bear season 3, that perspective faded.

Related

The Bear’s Berzatto Family Tree Explained

The Bear season 2 delves deeper into Carmen "Carmy" Berzatto's family dynamics - here is a breakdown of what his family tree would possibly look like.

While she may have seemed out of place in The Bear season 2, taking a back seat in The Bear season 3 really highlighted how necessary she was for Carmy to find balance. Not only that, but there also weren't really any other characters who weren't wrestling with something from their past, so there was no "Peace" to be had in almost any moment of the show's most recent season. So, Claire would be a welcome return as a more regular cast member in The Bear season 4.

The Bear Season 3 Confirms Claire’s Biggest Criticism Is Intentional With 1 Line From Carmy (5)
The Bear
The Bear Season 3 Confirms Claire’s Biggest Criticism Is Intentional With 1 Line From Carmy (6)

5.0

Comedy

Drama

Where to Watch

  • stream
  • rent
  • buy

Not available

Not available

*Availability in US

Set in a Chicago sandwich shop, The Bear follows Carmy Berzatto, a young professionally trained chef who returns to take over his family business after the unexpected death of his brother. At odds with many of the shop's employees due to his culinary training, Carmy struggles to maintain order and keep the shop from failing entirely. Jeremy Allen White stars as Carmy alongside Ebon Moss-Bachrach and Ayo Edebiri.

Cast
Jeremy Allen White , Ebon Moss-Bachrach , Ayo Edebiri , Lionel Boyce , Liza Colón-Zayas , Abby Elliott , Oliver Platt

Release Date
June 23, 2022

Seasons
2
Streaming Service(s)
Hulu , Disney+

Showrunner
Christopher Storer
  • The Bear (2022)

Your changes have been saved

Email Is sent

Please verify your email address.

You’ve reached your account maximum for followed topics.

Manage Your List

Follow

Followed

Follow with Notifications

Follow

Unfollow

The Bear Season 3 Confirms Claire’s Biggest Criticism Is Intentional With 1 Line From Carmy (2025)

FAQs

Was the review good or bad in The Bear season 3? ›

And the critical response seemed unfavorable! “A bad show in especially annoying ways,” wrote Jack Hamilton at Slate. “Not The Bear at its best,” wrote Rebecca Nicholson in the Guardian. “Frustrating to watch,” wrote Sophie Gilbert in The Atlantic.

What happened with The Bear in season 3? ›

“The Bear” Season 3 begins and ends with a funeral. But in the finale, it's a restaurant being mourned. The episode begins with a peaceful flashback to Carmy's (Jeremy Allen White) first day working at the French Laundry.

Why does The Bear season 3 end with to be continued? ›

When he spoke with Mr. Porter, he explained that they ended up filming more than they initially planned: We were going to make one season, but that season was getting bigger and bigger and at a certain point it seemed like maybe we should write more, not feel constrained and turn it into two seasons.

What is the best episode of The Bear Season 3? ›

“Napkins" (Season 3, Episode 6)

Directed by Ayo Edebiri, “Napkins” is one of the show's best flashback episodes, focusing entirely on Tina and how she became part of The Beef restaurant's extended family.

What are critics saying about The Bear? ›

Since its pilot episode, The Bear has been showered in accolades from critics, who call it an extraordinary show that has an ear for true-to-life dialogue, irresistible characters whose pain and stress (and there's a lot of stress here) seem to be deeply empathized with by the show's writers.

Is The Bear getting a season 4? ›

Who is in The Bear season four? In addition to White, Edebiri, and Moss-Bachrach, expect The Bear's core staff to return, including Liza Colón-Zayas's sous chef Tina, Abby Elliott's new mom Sugar, the Faks—Matty Matheson as Neil and Ricky Staffieri as Ted—and Lionel Boyce's pastry chef Marcus.

What happened to Carmy's hand? ›

Carmy once touched a pan so hot that it didn't even hurt, even though it left a massive scar on his hand. Claire humbles him a bit, telling a story from the hospital about a woman who violently fell through a glass table.

Will Carmy and Sydney get together? ›

Bad news, chefs. If you were rooting for a romantic storyline between Carmy and Sydney on The Bear, it's not happening. No matter how many fancams you've saved (or edited) or that footage you thought you saw of Jeremy Allen White and Ayo Edebiri at a baseball game.

Whose funeral is the bear season 3 episode 1? ›

A flashback sequence in The Bear's season 3 premiere reveals that Carmy observed Mikey's funeral from his car, but he didn't actually go inside. This is because he wasn't ready to accept that his brother was gone.

Why was Sydney sick at the end of The Bear? ›

Sydney, finally overcome by the anxiety and stress of opening night, throws up several times behind the restaurant, where her dad (Robert Townsend) tells her he's proud of her for finding "the thing" she's meant to do.

How is Richie related to Carmy? ›

Despite affectionately referring to each other as "cousin," Richie and Carmy aren't actually related.

Did The Bear end on a cliffhanger? ›

It took two days to binge the ten new episodes of The Bear season 3, which featured some stellar episodes including its premiere and the Ayo Edebiri-directed Napkins. But when you reach the end, the show ends on a cliffhanger that is very frustrating, and reminds me of a totally unrelated show, The Walking Dead.

Did they film season 4 of The Bear? ›

Despite the dust having barely settled on the third season of The Bear, one of its leading stars has now confirmed that the filming for its fourth outing has finished, it's now just a matter of when the network chooses to broadcast it.

What is the best season of The Bear? ›

Here's why it's still the best on TV. The first season of “The Bear,” FX's Emmy-magnet series about the workings and florid dysfunctions of a Chicago family and the restaurant they run, was great. The second season, however improbably, was even better. The question — the problem — then becomes, how to top it?

What is the most stressful episode of The Bear? ›

The 7 Most Stressful Episodes of "The Bear", Ranked
  1. Season 2, Episode 7: Fishes.
  2. Season 2, Episode 10: The Bear. Chuck Hodes. ...
  3. Season 1, Episode 7: Review. FX/Hulu. ...
  4. Season 3, Episode 8: Ice Chips. FX/Hulu. ...
  5. Season 3, Episode 6: Napkins. FX/Hulu. ...
  6. Season 1, Episode 8: Braciole. Photo: Matt Dinerstein. ...
  7. Season 3, Episode 2: Next. FX/Hulu. ...
Jul 1, 2024

Why did Tina quit The Bear? ›

Tina started to lose hope after constant rejection, which led to her stopping at Mikey's sandwich shop (Jon Bernthal) before heading home. Tina shared an emotional conversation with Mikey that ended with her accepting a job as a line cook.

Is The Bear bad this season? ›

Reviews have been more mixed for Season 3 than the previous two outings. On social media, there are viewers posting their not-so-stellar reactions to the new episodes. At the very least, people are feeling emboldened to articulate that, apparently, they never really liked the show in the first place.

Who kills old Ben in The Bear? ›

Boon Hogganbeck draws his knife and throws himself on top of the bear, slitting his throat. Old Ben dies, and a few days later, Lion dies as well. Sam Fathers collapses after the fight and dies not long after Lion.

Top Articles
Latest Posts
Recommended Articles
Article information

Author: Dean Jakubowski Ret

Last Updated:

Views: 5405

Rating: 5 / 5 (50 voted)

Reviews: 89% of readers found this page helpful

Author information

Name: Dean Jakubowski Ret

Birthday: 1996-05-10

Address: Apt. 425 4346 Santiago Islands, Shariside, AK 38830-1874

Phone: +96313309894162

Job: Legacy Sales Designer

Hobby: Baseball, Wood carving, Candle making, Jigsaw puzzles, Lacemaking, Parkour, Drawing

Introduction: My name is Dean Jakubowski Ret, I am a enthusiastic, friendly, homely, handsome, zealous, brainy, elegant person who loves writing and wants to share my knowledge and understanding with you.